22 maj: Den nye Continental GTC er smuk og stærk som bare f…..
26 maj: Skattereform 2012
23-05-2012 01:14:00

UPDATE: Facebook Forecasts Were Revised, But Only Some Knew -Sources

Relateret indhold

--Ire grows over news Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs updated financial projections for Facebook ahead of IPO

--Revised figures are typically only passed along to certain investors

--Massachusetts subpoenas Morgan Stanley for details

(Rewrites throughout.)

By Lynn Cowan and Liz Moyer

Analysts for at least two of Facebook Inc.'s (FB) lead underwriters revised their financial forecasts for the company while it was holding initial-public-offering "road-show" meetings with investors, according to people close to the deal.

The revised figures were only passed along to some investors, according to Scott Sweet, an adviser with IPO Boutique who worked with hedge funds and others that were buying into the deal. That is standard industry practice, but Sweet said it angered some who didn't get the updated figures.

Morgan Stanley (MS) and Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS) updated their financial projections for the social network after the company added warnings to its IPO prospectus about how its user base is increasing more rapidly than the number of ads it delivers, according to the people close to the deal. That ad trend was blamed in part on increased use of Facebook on mobile devices, where it traditionally hasn't shown ads to viewers.

Although the exact date of the analyst revisions wasn't clear, the people close to the deal said they were changed soon after Facebook updated its prospectus May 9, about a week before the offering priced.

The analyst revisions were previously reported by Reuters, which also cited underwriter J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. (JPM) as having revised its estimates.

Sweet, a senior managing partner at IPO Boutique, said his hedge-fund clients had different experiences depending on whether they knew about the revisions. One told him it learned about the revision while Facebook and its underwriters were still pitching the deal to investors, and this client made profits by selling its IPO shares Friday while shares were on the rise. Other hedge funds who didn't know about the analysts' financial projections for Facebook before the IPO held the shares, which have since fallen in value, and these investors are angry as a result, Sweet said.

In a statement Tuesday, a Morgan Stanley spokesman said the company "followed the same procedures for the Facebook offering that it follows for all IPOs. These procedures are in compliance with all applicable regulations."

Also on Tuesday, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority addressed allegations Morgan Stanley, which was the lead underwriter, may have shared negative news before the offering with only institutional investors. "If true, the allegations are a matter of regulatory concern to Finra and the SEC," said Rick Ketchum, Finra's chairman and chief executive.

A spokeswoman for the Securities and Exchange Commission declined to comment.

Separately, William Galvin, Massachusetts's secretary of the commonwealth, said he had issued a subpoena to Morgan Stanley "in connection with the discussions by their analyst with certain institutional investors about the revenue prospects for Facebook."

Facebook's stock fell 8.9% Tuesday after losing 11% Monday.

Large institutions, whose interest in a stock offering is key to setting its price, would have known about Facebook's filing and the analyst revisions at least seven business days before they placed final orders for the IPO, according to people familiar with the situation.

In Goldman Sachs's case, the research revision was verbally communicated to prospective buyers by the Goldman sales team, according to someone familiar with the situation.

Underwriters are barred by SEC rules from publicly issuing research on the IPOs they are involved in. But analysts who work for banks underwriting the deal are allowed to discuss their views with clients ahead of the offering.

"Once access [to public information] is readily available, brokerages have clients--they can talk to their clients, and they're not obligated to talk to everyone," former SEC Chairman Harvey Pitt said. "As long as information has become generally available, that's not going to raise any hackles." Pitt is now CEO of consultantcy Kalorama Partners LLC.

People familiar with the offering said the only unusual component in the analyst projections for Facebook was how close to the offering date the revisions took place. The trigger for that was Facebook's own revised SEC filing, which gave additional warnings about its mobile-user growth and advertising.

However, these people said, the way the information was broadcast to only some investors is standard industry practice. Investment bank analysts only give out verbal information on their financial modeling to large institutional clients with whom they have had continuing discussions about an IPO. They generally don't communicate directly with individual investors.

While individual investors interested in the Facebook IPO would have received updated SEC filings from their broker, the only way an individual would find out about an analyst's projections would be by calling his or her broker. The broker would then have to pick up the phone and contact the firm's sales team, which could then relay the verbal information about an analyst's estimates for future financial projections.

Goldman's customer base overwhelmingly skews toward large institutions, unlike Morgan Stanley, which also has a large retail customer base.

Individual investors with accounts at firms where analysts weren't modeling Facebook's future financial data would have even less information; analysts at an investment bank only communicate with their own firm's clients, because they aren't allowed to publicly disseminate research during an IPO under the SEC's quiet-period restrictions

(Matt Jarzemsky and Brett Philbin contributed to this article.)

-By Lynn Cowan and Liz Moyer, Dow Jones Newswires; 202-257-2740; lynn.cowan@dowjones.com

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

May 22, 2012 19:14 ET (23:14 GMT)

Copyright (c) 2012 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.

Opret kommentar

Relateret debat

  • 1 uge
  • 1 måned
  • 1 År
12 okt
GS
Tror du seriøst ikke, at der var danske kapitalforvaltere og private investorer, som kunne finde 8 m..
5
12 okt
GS
i al væsentlighed tror jeg også salget er foretaget på en OK måde, når det nu skulle være. Jeg er så..
3
12 okt
GS
igen - Dong blev ikke børsnoteret. Man børsnoterer ikke selskaber i krise - din valueringsmodet her ..
3
12 okt
GS
det tør jeg ikke sige noget om; men jeg har ingen grund til tvivle på, at de havde brug for penge. D..
3
12 okt
GS
Der er intet bagklogt i det. Jeg havde kaldt værdien pr. aktie til at være 100 kr. mere ved salget o..
3
14 okt
GS
Logikken er, at shorts er langt de bedste til at opdage svindel og lign. Det er ofte ikke longs, rev..
2
12 okt
GS
det er underligt, at man på et aktiesite skal  sidde og skrive at egenkapital og handelsværdi intet,..
2
12 okt
GS
nu var der ikke tale om nogen børsnotering, hvor prisen formentlig havde været endnu lavere. Jeg ful..
2
12 okt
GS
Lad nu være, du ved jo udmærket at valuering af virksomheder aldrig svare til den bogførte egenkapit..
2
12 okt
GS
prøver du at bilde os og dig selv ind, at du kunne beregne værdien af dong i efteråret 2013?   Jeg k..
2

Fondsbørsmeddelelser

Nye digitale betalingsløsninger bryder frem

25-09-2017 08:45:00
Sponsoreret indhold:Af Jens Damgaard, Country Manager, Visa DenmarkEfter 20 år, hvor danskerne har taget imod ganske mange nye løsninger indenfor elektroniske/digitale betalinger, går udviklingen nu endnu hurtigere, og det gør Danmark til et af de mest avancerede betalingsmarkeder i Europa. Avanceret, fordi danskerne er parat til at bruge næsten enhver tænkelig mobil enhed til at betale med.Buti..

Novo: Fiasp godkendt i USA

29-09-2017 16:20:48
De amerikanske sundhedsmyndigheder, FDA, har godkendt Fiasp (hurtigtvirkende insulin aspart), en ny hurtigtvirkende måltidsinsulin, til behandling af voksne med diabetes.Det oplyser Novo Nordisk.FDA's beslutning kommer, efter at kliniske studier har dokumenteret, at Fiasp giver fordele for mennesker, der har behov for en forbedret generel blodsukkerregulering.- Vi er meget glade for, at Fiasp nu o..

Atlantic Petroleum: Direktør fratræder 1. december

29-09-2017 14:02:37
Topchefen for Atlantic Petroleum, der er noteret i Norge og København, direktør Ben Arabo, har opsagt sit job for at tiltræde et andet job på Færøerne.Det oplyser selskabet.Han vil dog blive hos Atlantic Petroleum til 1. december./ritzau/FINANSClaus Mikkelsen +45 33 30 03 35 Ritzau Finans, E-mail: finans@ritzau.dk , www.ritzaufinans.dk

Mest læste nyheder

  • 24 timer
  • 48 timer
  • 1 uge
1
Novo/Sydbank: Ser aktien stige 3-4 pct. efter positiv anbefaling
2
Novo: Mulig milliardsællerts skæbne er i eksperternes hænder - GENT
3
Aktier/middag: Tunge Novo trækker C20 ud i overhalingsbanen
4
GN-retssag om 3,8 milliarder kan blive afgjort onsdag aften
5
ISS får sin største kontrakt nogensinde på 33 milliarder over ti år

Relaterede aktiekurser

JP Morgan Chase & Co 97,99 0,0% Aktiekurs uændret
Goldman Sachs Group Inc .. 242,03 0,0% Aktiekurs uændret
Morgan Stanley 50,15 0,0% Aktiekurs uændret
Facebook Inc 176,03 0,0% Aktiekurs uændret

Køb- og salgsanbefalinger

  • Trend
  • Pengemaskinen

Copyright Euroinvestor A/S 2017  Disclaimer Privatlivspolitik
Aktieinformation leveres af Morningstar.
Data er forsinket 15-20 minutter iht. de enkelte børsers regler om videredistribution.
 
19. oktober 2017 10:58:43
(UTC+01:00) Brussels, Copenhagen, Madrid, Paris
Version: LiveBranchBuild_20171017.1 - EUROWEB3 - 2017-10-19 10:58:43 - 2017-10-19 10:58:43 - 1 - Website: OKAY