18 jun: Ny opdateret BMW 7-serie
20 jun: Is i champagnen - Helligbrøde eller et frisk pust?
18-06-2012 19:50:00

UPDATE: US Supreme Court Rejects Overtime Pay for Drug Representatives

Relateret indhold

--Supreme Court rules 5-4 that drug representatives are exempt from overtime-pay requirements

--Ruling is a significant win for the pharmaceutical industry

--Court's decision rejects the Labor Department's position

(Updates with Glaxo comment and details from the ruling.)

By Brent Kendall

WASHINGTON--The Supreme Court ruled Monday that drug companies don't have to pay their sales representatives for working overtime hours, a significant win for the pharmaceutical industry.

The court, in a 5-4 opinion written by Justice Samuel Alito, ruled that drug sales representatives fall under a provision of federal labor law that removes overtime-pay requirements for those employed as outside salespeople.

The court's ruling, which split the court along ideological lines, rejected arguments by the Department of Labor in favor of overtime pay. The department had argued the outside-sales exemption shouldn't apply because drug representatives don't actually sell medicines to doctors but merely promote them.

Justice Alito dismissed that argument as "quite unpersuasive," saying drug representatives effectively function as salespeople "in the unique regulatory environment within which pharmaceutical companies must operate."

A sales representative's job is to obtain nonbinding commitments from doctors to prescribe a particular drug in appropriate cases, and doctors must prescribe the product "if any sale is to take place at all," Justice Alito said in the 25-page opinion.

Justice Alito, joined by the court's four other conservative justices, said deferring to the Labor Department's interpretation of overtime regulations would impose "potentially massive liability" on pharmaceutical companies without fair warning.

Drug companies have classified their sales representatives as overtime-exempt for decades but the Labor Department didn't suggest the industry was acting unlawfully until 2009, Justice Alito said. He noted that the department announced its position in a series of court briefs instead of relying on normal rulemaking procedures that would have given the public a chance to comment.

The court's four liberal justices dissented. Justice Stephen Breyer, writing for the dissenters, said drug representatives aren't salespeople because their primary duty is to provide doctors with information about their pharmaceutical products. If a particular drug is the best treatment for a patient, a doctor will prescribe it "irrespective of any nonbinding commitment" he made to a sales representative, Justice Breyer said.

Monday's decision came in a case involving GlaxoSmithKline PLC (GSK, GSK.LN), which was fighting legal claims from two former salesmen who were seeking overtime pay on behalf of a nationwide class of representatives employed by the drug maker.

The case held high stakes for the industry, which spends billions each year promoting drugs to doctors in the U.S. Lower courts had issued conflicting rulings on whether the sales representatives were eligible for overtime pay.

The Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America, the drug industry's main trade group, had warned in a court brief that classifying sales representatives as eligible for overtime could expose drug companies to retroactive liability and cost the industry billions of dollars.

Glaxo, in a statement, said the ruling "should bring an end to the rash of costly and misguided classification lawsuits being brought against the industry."

Pharmaceutical-sales representatives are typically paid a combination of base salary and performance-based commission. In addition, they are usually given a car or an allowance for a car. Many salespeople work long days trying to track down doctors, sometimes waiting until after office hours for a few minutes of face time.

Glaxo said the industry approach to compensation is fair, "and recognizes that sales professionals need the flexibility to schedule their work in a way that accommodates their schedules and the busy schedules of the healthcare providers they serve."

Neither the Labor Department nor the plaintiffs in the case immediately responded to requests for comment.

The case is Christopher v. SmithKline Beecham, 11-204.

Write to Brent Kendall at brent.kendall@dowjones.com

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

June 18, 2012 13:50 ET (17:50 GMT)

Copyright (c) 2012 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.

Opret kommentar

Relateret debat

  • 1 uge
  • 1 måned
  • 1 År
Ingen indlæg

Aktier/tendens: Nye C25-medlemmer, DSV og Vestas i fokus

18-06-2018 08:36:55
Tre nye selskaber indtræder mandag i det danske eliteindeks C25, hvor der også vil komme fokus på DSV efter en sænket analytikeranbefaling og Vestas efter en stor amerikansk ordre. Umiddelbart peger det i retning af en negativ aktieåbning i Europa, hvor den tyske DAX-future ligger 0,5 pct. lavere efter fald i de amerikanske aktiefutures og en generel sur stemning på de asiatiske børser. Det er for..

Spar Nord optager lån på 400 mio. kr.

15-06-2018 13:48:15
Spar Nord vil i næste uge optage et lån på 400 mio. kr., der har status af supplerende kapital. Et mindre antal professionelle investorer har lånt banken pengene. Lånet har en løbetid på ti år, men der er mulighed for at betale det ud efter fem år. De første fem år er renten på 2,53 pct., og udstedelsen vil gælde fra 19. juni, oplyser Spar Nord i en meddelelse til fondsbørsen. Supplerende kapital ..

Mærsk: Fragtraterne falder for anden uge i træk

15-06-2018 09:23:33
Spotpriserne på containerfragt faldt 3,5 pct. til 777,70 i denne uge ifølge rateindekset Shanghai Containerized Freight Index (SCFI). Dermed fortsætter sidste uges fald, efter at priserne ellers var steget de to foregående uger.Indekset har bevæget sig en del, siden det var nede at vende i årets bund i 568,68 i slutningen af marts.SCFI-indekset sammensættes på baggrund af spotprisen på fragt fra S..

Mest læste nyheder

  • 24 timer
  • 48 timer
  • 1 uge
1
Aktier/tendens: Nye C25-medlemmer, DSV og Vestas i fokus
2
KORR: Vestas: Modtager storordre på 442 MW i USA - GENT
3
Vestas/Sydbank: Regner med stærk afslutning på andet kvartal
4
DSV/Morningstar: Sænker anbefalingen til "sælg"
5
Mærsk/Clarksons: Skærer 20 pct af kursmålet - GENT

Relaterede aktiekurser

Abbott Laboratories 62,91 -0,1% Fald i aktiekurs
Eli Lilly and Company 86,88 0,6% Stigning i aktiekurs
Glaxosmithkline PLC ORD .. 1.550,40 -0,4% Fald i aktiekurs
GlaxoSmithKline PLC 41,44 -1,2% Fald i aktiekurs
Lilly ELI 85,00 0,0% Aktiekurs uændret

Køb- og salgsanbefalinger

  • Trend
  • Pengemaskinen

Copyright Euroinvestor A/S 2018  Disclaimer  |  Cookie- og privatlivspolitik  |  Persondatapolitik
Aktieinformation leveres af Morningstar.
Data er forsinket 15-20 minutter iht. de enkelte børsers regler om videredistribution.
 
18. juni 2018 11:06:53
(UTC+01:00) Brussels, Copenhagen, Madrid, Paris
Version: LiveBranchBuild_20180613.1 - EUROWEB1 - 2018-06-18 11:06:53 - 2018-06-18 11:06:53 - 1 - Website: OKAY